2 hearts to pick, 1 to win over

Ok, so.My name is Mckayla. I’m 15. And I have some problems…
I have a boyfriend, his name is Evan. But the problem just isnt with him, it concerns another boy too.
My bestfriend’s name is Nick. We tell each other everything, and he has a girlfriend too. Me and Nick have a lot of things in common. We consider our selves the same stereotype. We dress pretty much the same, we talk the same. We like the same music, websites, tv shows. Me and Nick started spending a lot of time together when I started to have some social problems involving friends, family, etc.